Legal News

Patent Infringement Cases Now Able to Get Legal Fees Reimbursed
Download PDF
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)


Summary: A U.S. Supreme Court case from a year ago, Octane, has made it possible for other companies that get sued for patent infringement to get back their legal fees when the lawsuit was meritless.

Octane Fitness has asked for $2.8 million in legal fees from the U.S. District Court for the District of Minnesota Federal Judge Ann Montgomery. This small Minnesota company has changed the rules regarding awarded attorney fees in patent litigation.


Over a year ago, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled against the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit’s explanation for the common award of attorney fees, calling the standard rigid and inflexible. The High Court decided that District courts should have the right to make their own decision regarding a company being entitled to having attorney fees paid back.

Over seven years ago, Octane was sued by ICON Health & Fitness for patent infringement. A lawsuit Octane called “meritless”. ICON manufactures NordikTrack and other exercise equipment. Judge Montgomery found through the evidence presented that ICON took a lot of time to find a patent of theirs that they could “throw” at Octane. They ended up on a 10-year-old patent that had not been commercialized and was “sitting on the shelf”. ICON then took the trouble to drive up Octane’s litigation costs, trying to get them to settle instead of defending their lawsuit. She called their behavior “uncommon, rare, and not ordinary”.

Three years after the initial lawsuit was filed by ICON, Octane’s motion for summary judgement was granted by the district court, citing that no infringement had occurred. Octane then requested their legal fees to be reimbursed but the district and Federal Circuit said their case was not eligible for reimbursement.

Get JD Journal in Your Mail

Subscribe to our FREE daily news alerts and get the latest updates on the most happening events in the legal, business, and celebrity world. You also get your daily dose of humor and entertainment!!

Octane then took their fight to the U.S. Supreme Court arguing that the standard was not attainable and, therefore, not right. All nine judges agreed and have now made it possible for district courts to award legal fees when the patent holder sues with no good chance of winning.

The case last year, commonly known as Octane, has made it possible for 30 other companies throughout the country to be awarded their legal fees. From 2005 to 2011, there were no fees awarded to cases where the patent holder had a weak chance of winning their lawsuit.




Interesting Legal Sites You May Like




Search Now

Litigator with 5-10 years of general insurance defense experience

USA-FL-West Palm Beach

Boutique litigation firm is looking for an experienced litigator with 5-10 years of general insuranc...

Apply Now

Transactional Real Estate Attorney with 4-10 years of experience

USA-CA-San Diego

San Diego office is seeking a transactional real estate attorney with 4-10 years of experience.

Apply Now

Real Estate/Business Transaction Attorney with 8+ years of experience


Seattle office is seeking a real estate & business transaction attorney with 8+ years of experience....

Apply Now

Litigation Attorney with 2-5 years of insurance coverage experience


Towson office of our client seeks litigation attorney with 2-5 years of business, insurance coverage...

Apply Now


Contract Attorney

USA-CA-Beverly Hills

We are looking for a civil business litigator with 3+ years of experience who is capable of attendin...

Apply now


USA-CA-San Francisco

As an in-house legal counsel at Wix’s legal department, you will play a significant role in de...

Apply now

Experienced Insurance Defense Attorney Needed


Defense Negligence firm with offices in Nassau County and main office in Suffolk County seeks a full...

Apply now


USA-MO-Kansas City

Successful, expanding KC personal injury law firm seeks an attorney with 5+ years personal injury li...

Apply now

Most Popular


To Top