Bad Lawyers

Leigh Day Lawyers Failed to Release Detainee List
Download PDF
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)

Leigh Day

Summary: Lawyers for Leigh Day  claim “human error” over failure to release a list of their clients’ military association in relation to the Battle of Danny Boy ambush and Al-Sweady Inquiry.

A twist in the facts has turned things around for three Leigh Day lawyers. Martyn Day, Sapna Malik and Anna Crowther, all Leigh Day lawyers, represented clients from Iraq in their allegation against British soldiers. The truth of who the clients actually are has come forward, changing the validity of the claims.


The Leigh Day lawyers represented members of a militia of the Mahdi Army, a group which ambushed British troops. The Iraqi militia members claimed that British Army soldiers murdered, tortured and mutilated the Iraqi civilians. Leigh Day failed to properly disclose who their clients were during the compensation proceedings.

The tribunal is now hearing complaints about how the allegations from the members of the Iraqi “murderous” militia have caused years of suffering for the falsely accused soldiers. Day and Malik are facing 19 charges of misconduct while Crowther faces one charge of misconduct. Had the firm not withheld the information of who their clients are, a £31m public inquiry into the claims likely would not have needed to happen.

Timothy Dutton QC, who is representing the Solicitors Regulation Authority said, “Over a period of more than seven years, Martyn Day, Sapna Malik and Leigh Day made and maintained allegations that soldiers in the British Army had murdered, tortured, and mutilated Iraqi civilians.” He further explained that the lawyers had in their possession since 2004 the Shia militia group Office of the Martyr Al-Sadr detainee list which “’undermined their clients’ claims they were innocent bystanders in the Battle of Danny Boy.”

Get JD Journal in Your Mail

Subscribe to our FREE daily news alerts and get the latest updates on the most happening events in the legal, business, and celebrity world. You also get your daily dose of humor and entertainment!!

The battle in question occurred on May 14 when the British Army entered into an attack brought on up Iraqi insurgents of the Mahdi Army outside the city of Al Amara.

The tribunal received word that Leigh Day received around £9.5 million for their work on the case. The firm claims they did not commit any professional wrongdoing. They claim the lack of disclosing the detainee list was “human error” and not on purpose.

Dutton explains that if the list had been provided, legal aid would most likely not have been made available to Public Interest Lawyers and the inquiry, dubbed Al-Sweady, would not have progressed. Public Interests Lawyers submitted multiple allegations of misconduct by British soldiers. The group has since closed down and the lead lawyer, Phil Shiner, has been struck off over any misconduct.

Dutton said, “If the respondents had discharged their duties, British soldiers and their families would not have had to endure torment and years of worry arising from false accusations endorsed by solicitors and members of the profession, made not just in claims but to the world’s media.”

The findings of the Al-Sweady inquiry were that some soldiers’ actions breached the Geneva Convention. However, the claims were highly criticized from the beginning of the investigation. The same investigation found that British forces responded to the ambush with “exemplary courage, resolution and professionalism.”

Do you think the list should have been released? Tell us in the comments below.

To learn more about Iraq cases, read these articles:





USA-CA-Westlake Village

Small, congenial, well-established Westlake Village, CA, law firm seeking attorney with minimum 10+ ...

Apply now

Legal Assistant


Position Lancaster Law Firm is seeking a full-time legal assistant. The firm assists its clients, p...

Apply now

Part-Time Estate Planning and Elder Law Paralegal

USA-MI-New Baltimore

Chawla Legal Group is looking for an experienced paralegal to help expand into the worlds of probate...

Apply now



Seeking a Family Law Associate Attorney with minimum 3-5 years experience in Family Law.  Candi...

Apply now




Search Now

Real Estate Attorney

USA-SC-North Charleston

North Charleston office of our client seeks real estate attorney with experience. The candidate will...

Apply Now

Senior Family Law Litigation Attorney


Corona office of our client seeks senior family law litigation attorney with 10+ years of experience...

Apply Now

Transactional Attorney

USA-IA-Iowa City

Iowa City office of a BCG Attorney Search Top Ranked Law Firm seeks transactional attorney with 2+ y...

Apply Now

Most Popular


To Top