Legal News

Judge Rules in Favor of Amazon in Patent Case
Download PDF
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)

A federal judge has ruled that patents that Amazon challenged cannot stand because they seek to patent ideas.

Summary: A federal judge has ruled that patents that Amazon challenged cannot stand because they seek to patent ideas.

U.S. District Judge Barbara Rothstein ruled on Wednesday that online ecommerce patents that Amazon Inc. challenged as indefinite functional claiming were patent-ineligible, The Recorder reports.


Amazon and Google recently battled over a non-compete clause.

Amazon was represented by Fenwick & West and Latham & Watkins in the case. Judge Rothstein noted, “These claims describe nothing more than what buyers and sellers have done since the dawn of commerce, The only difference is that Telebuyer suggests the application of generalized computer function and technology in the transaction.”

Ronald Katz owns Telebuyer LLC. Katz also owns Ronald A. Katz Licensing Co., one of the country’s most successful nonpracticing entities. Katz and Telebuyer asserted seven patents that described methods of patching online buyers and sellers based on their histories. These methods directed buyers to items they were more likely to purchase.

Get JD Journal in Your Mail

Subscribe to our FREE daily news alerts and get the latest updates on the most happening events in the legal, business, and celebrity world. You also get your daily dose of humor and entertainment!!

Last year, HBO signed an agreement with Amazon Prime.

Amazon first attacked the patents as indefinite means-plus-function claims. Later, it argued “the rule against owning naked functions and the rule against owning naked ideas.”

Do you think there will be more infringement suits this year involving giant companies like Amazon?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

On Thursday, Rothstein agreed that the patents were drawn to ineligible subject matter because matching buyers and sellers is an abstract idea with no inventive concept.

Netflix recently won a method patent suit against Rovi.

The opinion read, “The representative claims are devoid of any specialized hardware, programming, system logic, or algorithms that would allow Telebuyer’s traffic control system to actually function. While Telebuyer describes the use of a data-driven traffic control system in e-commerce, it left to others the task of creating—i.e., inventing—the necessary algorithms and other specialized programming to achieve that system.”

Latham & Watkins partners Douglas Lumish, Matthew Moore, Gregory Garre, Richard Frenkel and Gabriel Gross led the team for Amazon. Brian Buckley of Fenwick & West and Amazon’s associate general counsel Jeffrey Dean also appeared at last month’s hearing.

O’Melveny & Myers partners Brian Berliner and Mark Samuels appeared for Telebuyer and Katz, who were joined by Yarmuth Wilsdon’s Jeremy Roller and counsel Xin-Yi “Vincent” Zhou.

Clockwise from top left: Berliner, Samuels, Zhou, Roller, Buckley

Clockwise from top left: Berliner, Samuels, Zhou, Roller, Buckley

According to GeekWire, patent litigation in the United States is expected to hit an all-time high by the end of 2015.

Source: The Recorder

Photo credit:, O’Melveny & Myers (Berliner, Samuels, Zhou), (Roller), Fenwick & West (Buckley)


Interesting Legal Sites You May Like




Search Now

General Municipal Law Attorney with land use experience


Oakland office of our client seeks general municipal law attorney with experience advising public ag...

Apply Now

Senior Land Use Attorney with experience

USA-CA-San Francisco

San Francisco office of our client seeks senior land use attorney with 7+ years of experience. The c...

Apply Now

Immigration Attorney with portable business


McLean office is seeking an immigration attorney with $500,000+ in portable business.

Apply Now

Commercial Litigation Attorney with 4+ years of experience


Chicago office of our client seeks commercial litigation attorney with 4+ years of experience. The c...

Apply Now


Litigation Associate (Junior to Mid-Level) - Medical Malpractice - Garden City, NY

USA-NY-Garden City

Defense firm seeking junior to mid-level associate for Garden City office to fill Medical Malpractic...

Apply now

Experienced Insurance Defense Attorney Needed


Insurance Defense firm (with 15 attorneys in Suffolk and Mineola location), seeks attorneys with 5+ ...

Apply now



Lang, Richert & Patch a Fresno area AV-rated law firm located in the highly desirable Fig Garden Fin...

Apply now



INSURANCE DEFENSE / TRANSPORTATION LITIGATION Law firm located in North Houston seeking an associ...

Apply now

Most Popular


To Top