Breaking News

Federal Judge Casts Doubt on the Constitutionality of NSA’s Mass Surveillance
Download PDF
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
Loading...

Judge Richard Leon of the US District Court for the District of Columbia has created a stir by becoming the first judge to cast doubt upon the constitutionality of the NSA’s mass collection of the telephone records of millions of Americans. While Judge Leon held in his ruling that the plaintiffs had legal standing to challenge the NSA’s practices, his scathing observations in the opinion are significant.

Immediately after issuing his opinion, the judge put a stay on his order pending the outcome of future litigation. The government is not expected to give up and the judge clearly anticipated an appeal.

  
What
Where


Judge Leon observed that the massive telephone record collection program was “almost Orwellian” in nature, and differentiated from legal precedents used to justify the program. Opining that NSA’s program was likely unconstitutional, Judge Leon wrote, “Because the government can use daily metadata collection to engage in ‘repetitive, surreptitious surveillance of a citizen’s private goings on,’ the NSA database ‘implicated the Fourth Amendment each time a government official monitors it.”

Leaving the government little room to maneuver, the opinion noted, “It’s one thing to say that police expect phone companies to occasionally provide information to law enforcement; it is quite another to suggest that our citizens expect all phone companies to operate what is effectively a joint intelligence-gathering operation with the government.”

The judge also observed that plaintiffs have a right of injunction against the NSA’s practice because earlier precedents like the case of Smith v. Maryland could not have considered the radical technological advances that took place in the last 34 years since the precedent was set.

Get JD Journal in Your Mail

Subscribe to our FREE daily news alerts and get the latest updates on the most happening events in the legal, business, and celebrity world. You also get your daily dose of humor and entertainment!!




In his 68-page memorandum, Judge Leon writes, “I am convinced that the surveillance program now before me is so different from a simple pen register” that earlier precedents are of little value in determining whether NSAs current program violates the Fourth Amendment.

In differentiating from precedents, the judge wrote, “Indeed, the question in this case can more properly be styled as follows: When do present-day circumstances – the evolutions in the government’s surveillance capabilities, citizens’ phone habits and the relation between the NSA and telecom companies – become so thoroughly unlike those considered by the Supreme Court that 34 years to a precedent like Smith simply does not apply? The answer, unfortunately for the government, is now.”



Observing that the collection of metadata by the NSA has done little to impede terrorist attacks, at least according to what the government submitted before the court, Judge Leon stated, “I believe that bulk telephone metadata collection and analysis almost certainly does violate a reasonable expectation of privacy.”



 

RELEVANT JOBS

Medical Malpractice Attorney

USA-CO-Denver

Hall & Evans, LLC, one of Denver\'s most recognized and respected law firms, is continuing its expan...

Apply now

Litigation Associate Attorney

USA-CO-Denver

Hall & Evans, L.L.C., one of Colorado\'s most established law firms, currently has an opportunity fo...

Apply now

Law Firm Office & Billing Administrator

USA-NY-New York City

The Law Offices of Patrick A. Mullin is a boutique tax defense and white-collar criminal defense law...

Apply now

Legal Secretary

USA-LA-New Orleans

A New Orleans litigation law firm is seeking an experienced Legal Assistant / Legal Secretary to und...

Apply now

BCG FEATURED JOB

Locations:

Keyword:



Search Now

Senior Real Estate Partner-level Attorney

USA-NY-New York City

New York City office of a BCG Attorney Search top ranked law firm seeks Senior Real Estate Partner-l...

Apply Now

Senior Staff Products Liability and Mass Torts Attorney

USA-CA-Los Angeles

Los Angeles office of our client seeks Senior Staff Products Liability and Mass Torts Attorney with ...

Apply Now

Partner-level Products Liability, Consumer Class Actions Attorney

USA-CA-Los Angeles

Los Angeles office of our client seeks Partner-level Products Liability, Consumer Class Actions Atto...

Apply Now

Most Popular

SEARCH IN ARCHIVE

To Top