Breaking News

Secret Court Opinion Warning DOJ of Unconstitutional NSA Surveillance Isn’t Protected by Secret Court Rules
Download PDF
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
Loading...

On Wednesday, in a public ruling quite foreign to the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court, the court’s chief judge Reggie Walton rejected arguments made by the DOJ for continuing to keep under wraps an FISC opinion, which held some NSA surveillance as unconstitutional.

While the DOJ argued that the 86-page opinion of the secret court, made in 2011, merited the same secrecy as court documents of the FISC, the secret court ruled otherwise.

According to the FISC, its opinion warning the DOJ of unconstitutional surveillance by NSA was now in the possession of the Department of Justice, and therefore subject to release under the Freedom of Information Act.

  
What
Where


In the seven-page opinion, FISC chief judge Reggie Walton held that the FISC rule for keeping FISC opinions sealed does not apply to the opinion, which had not been otherwise barred from disclosure and was already in the government’s possession.

The FISC indicated that the ball was no more in its court and referred the matter to the federal court, where the lawsuit was originally filed, for deciding whether the document was eligible for release under the Freedom of Information Act, and to what extent.

The FISC court observed “This court expresses no opinion on the other issues presented … including whether the opinion is ultimately subject to disclosure.”

Get JD Journal in Your Mail

Subscribe to our FREE daily news alerts and get the latest updates on the most happening events in the legal, business, and celebrity world. You also get your daily dose of humor and entertainment!!




The original lawsuit under the Freedom of Information Act was filed in a federal court by the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EEF) in 2012 for compelling disclosure of the FISC opinion. Though the Justice Department admitted that there was an 86-page opinion dated Oct. 3, 2011 that could be subject to the FOIA request, it argued that FISC documents were barred from public disclosure. To which, the FISC has now said that the document in question does not merit protection of ordinary FISC opinions.

The EEF brought the lawsuit after it learned of a letter sent in 2012 from an aide to James Clapper to Se. Ron Wyden, mentioning that at least on one occasion the FISC had held some collection of data under NSA surveillance programs as “unreasonable under the Fourth Amendment.” The letter also stated that the concerns had been taken care of and FISC has continued to approve data collection activities.



Wyden, as a member of the Senate Intelligence Committee, is barred from providing further details as long as the documents are not legally declassified.



 

Interesting Legal Sites You May Like


BCG FEATURED JOB

Locations:

Keyword:



Search Now

Mid-level Litigation Attorney

USA-CA-San Francisco

San Francisco office is seeking a mid-level litigation attorney with experience taking/defending dep...

Apply Now

Mid-level Litigation Attorney

USA-CA-San Francisco

San Francisco office is seeking a support attorney with some experience/familiarity with a litigatio...

Apply Now

Patent Prosecution Attorney

USA-MI-Northville

Northville office of our client seeks patent prosecution attorney with 5 years of experience. The ca...

Apply Now

Trademark and Copyright Associate Attorney

USA-CA-San Francisco

San Francisco office of our client seeks trademark and copyright associate attorney with 4-8 years o...

Apply Now

RELEVANT JOBS

Attorney - Insurance Defense

USA-GA-Atlanta

Downtown litigation law firm seeks associate with 3 to 5 years of experience in insurance defense, i...

Apply now

Legal Secretary-Cannabis Law Firm

USA-MI-Lansing

Vora, PLLC. Is accepting applications for a Legal Secretary or Paralegal. We are a cannabis law firm...

Apply now

Paralegal- Cannabis Law Firm

USA-MI-Lansing

Vora, PLLC. Is accepting applications for a Paralegal or Legal Secretary. We are a cannabis law...

Apply now

Legal Administrative Assistant

USA-CA-Sacramento

Under the general direction of the supervising attorney(s) and according to established Firm policie...

Apply now

SEARCH IN ARCHIVE

To Top