Law Students

Former Southern Illinois University Law Librarian Survives Motion to Dismiss
Download PDF
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)

Donald Jason Raymond, a former law librarian at Southern Illinois University, filed a lawsuit in 2011 against Southern Illinois University after being terminated in 2009.  His lawsuit survived a motion to dismiss, according to The National Law Journal.

In a motion to dismiss, the defense usually argues the plaintiff fails to state a claim. The defendant responds to procedural flaws in a complaint without responding to the merits of the case. The defendant requests a court to dismiss civil claims without legal merit.  The court determines if sufficient facts are pled to sustain a prima facie case for the alleged cause of action. The court does not evaluate the merits or go beyond the complaint.


The university allegedly terminated Raymond for allegedly threatening to “bash” a colleague with a crowbar. U.S. District Judge Michael Reagan on September 25, 2012 dismissed most of Raymond’s claims against the university and various administrators, but allowed two claims on retaliation by the university and former law dean Peter Alexander to proceed, and two claims of tortious interference against Alexander and colleague to proceed, provided Raymond re-pleads those counts by October 12, 2012.

Raymond claimed the law library colleague fabricated the crowbar threat to protect her job; that several administrators violated his rights by failing to fully investigate the circumstances before terminating him; and that the accusations have hindered his attempts to search for another job.

According Raymond’s complaint, a student library worker filed a sexual harassment claim against him, but no disciplinary action resulted, and Raymond never saw the complaint. In June 2009, Raymond learned a law library employee, Marilyn Jane Miller, obtained a copy of the student’s complaint, which was to be kept confidential under university’s policy. Miller showed Raymond the harassment complaint, against the instructions of her supervisor, according to Raymond’s complaint.

Get JD Journal in Your Mail

Subscribe to our FREE daily news alerts and get the latest updates on the most happening events in the legal, business, and celebrity world. You also get your daily dose of humor and entertainment!!

After showing the harassment complaint to Raymond, Miller told library director Douglas Lind she gave the complaint to Raymond. Lind said he would take the matter to former law dean Alexander, according to Reagan’s ruling. Miller then told her supervisor Raymond threatened to hit her supervisor with a crowbar, and later told administrators Raymond frequently made similar threats against the supervisor, the judge wrote.

Southern Illinois hired Raymond in 2008 Raymond, after he worked as a law librarian at Cravath, Swaine & Moore and Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison. The university hired him as a tenure-track assistant professor and law librarian, according to his complaint. He had a 12-month contract.

Alexander gave Raymond a letter detailing the threats, and Raymond was escorted off campus, over his protestations that the allegations were not true, read Reagan’s ruling. In its motion to dismiss, the university argued it followed proper procedures in placing Raymond on administrative leave with pay for two years. Reagan described Raymond as having been “effectively terminated.”


Interesting Legal Sites You May Like




Search Now

General Municipal Law Attorney with land use experience


Oakland office of our client seeks general municipal law attorney with experience advising public ag...

Apply Now

Senior Land Use Attorney with experience

USA-CA-San Francisco

San Francisco office of our client seeks senior land use attorney with 7+ years of experience. The c...

Apply Now

Immigration Attorney with portable business


McLean office is seeking an immigration attorney with $500,000+ in portable business.

Apply Now

Commercial Litigation Attorney with 4+ years of experience


Chicago office of our client seeks commercial litigation attorney with 4+ years of experience. The c...

Apply Now


Managing Director, Litigation Finance Investments


Title                ...

Apply now

Contract Associate


Seeking lawyer with at least 2 yrs experience in complex real estate transactional matters, with wil...

Apply now



Growing full-service law firm based in Fort Collins and Greeley is seeking a full time Paralegal. Th...

Apply now



Our Syracuse, NY office seeks an Associate with 3-5 years experience defending general liabilit...

Apply now

Most Popular


To Top