Legal News

Chivalry Still Alive in Federal Court
Download PDF
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
Loading...

A recent study shows interesting differences in rulings depending on the genders of the judges on the bench.

Summary: A recent study shows interesting differences in rulings depending on the genders of the judges on the bench.

According to the Wall Street Journal’s Law Blog, chivalry is still alive and well in some parts of the world—particularly in the federal court system in the United States.

  
What
Where


A recent study looked at how male judges decide cases. Other studies have examined how male and female judges differ, but this group of researchers examined how male qualities impact the decisions in court cases.

Professors Michael Kagan, Rebecca D. Gill, and Fatma Marouf studied 100 immigration cases in the 11 federal appellate courts that review them. Each case is decided by a panel of three judges.

Louisiana’s longest sitting judge has been ordered off the bench.

Get JD Journal in Your Mail

Subscribe to our FREE daily news alerts and get the latest updates on the most happening events in the legal, business, and celebrity world. You also get your daily dose of humor and entertainment!!




The researchers predicted that chivalry theory would be supported, or that men view women as “damsels in distress” who need to be protected, so male judges would be kinder to female litigants. Additionally, they predicted that judges would be stricter on male litigants if they pleaded for residency, because this demonstrated vulnerability. According to masculinity theory, which the researches expected to find, men are taught that they should not be emotional or vulnerable, so male judges may be harder on those who appeared this way in court.

In February, a judge was indicted for racial abuse.



The researchers were correct. Female litigants had “significantly better” results if the panel was all male than if they had been in front of mix-gender panels. Male litigants received less favorable rulings if they were in front of male panels instead of mixed gender panels.

Do you think female litigants receive lighter punishments in court?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

The authors also predicted that adding one female judge to the panel would neutralize any gender bias. However, men had better results with mixed panels than women did.

One woman’s case was dismissed by a judge when she had an outburst.

The study read, “While all-male panels are more favorable to female litigants and less so to male litigants, adding female judges to the panel seems to reverse this effect without achieving equality. That there is a significant difference between the grant rates presents a new problem … Are all-male panels too lenient on women and too hard on men? Are mixed panels too lenient on men and too hard on women? Our results provide no clear answer to these questions. Instead, our results suggest that the impact of gender on judging is highly dynamic.”

Source: The Wall Street Journal Law Blog

Photo credit: ctpost.com



 

Interesting Legal Sites You May Like


BCG FEATURED JOB

Locations:

Keyword:



Search Now

General Municipal Law Attorney with land use experience

USA-CA-Oakland

Oakland office of our client seeks general municipal law attorney with experience advising public ag...

Apply Now

Senior Land Use Attorney with experience

USA-CA-San Francisco

San Francisco office of our client seeks senior land use attorney with 7+ years of experience. The c...

Apply Now

Immigration Attorney with portable business

USA-VA-McLean

McLean office is seeking an immigration attorney with $500,000+ in portable business.

Apply Now

Attorney with 1-2 years of business immigration experience

USA-IL-Chicago

Chicago office of our client seeks attorney with 1-2 years of business immigration experience. The c...

Apply Now

RELEVANT JOBS

LITIGATION ATTORNEY

USA-CA-Emeryville

Boutique East Bay litigation defense firm is seeking a junior to mid-level attorney. Candidates for ...

Apply now

Managing Director, Litigation Finance Investments

USA-FL-Tampa

Title                ...

Apply now

Contract Associate

USA-CA-Sausalito

Seeking lawyer with at least 2 yrs experience in complex real estate transactional matters, with wil...

Apply now

Products Liability & Mass Tort Litigation Associate

USA-GA-Atlanta

The candidate must have 1- 5 years of civil litigation experience, preferably with some background i...

Apply now

Most Popular

SEARCH IN ARCHIVE

To Top