Legal News

Can State Social Workers Decide Which Sex an Infant Should Have?
Download PDF
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)

On Tuesday, in a first of its kind case, a South Carolina couple has sued doctors and state social workers for submitting a 16-month-old child to surgery and assign sex according to their choice. The child, who was born with male and female genitalia was subjected to irreversible sex-assignment surgery with his male genitalia removed while he was a toddler and still in foster care. The couple later adopted the child, and learned of the predicament.

They have filed lawsuits in both state and federal courts asking whether doctors and social workers had the right to decide whether the infant’s body should appear to be female or male, when they were not in a position to predict how the gender of the infant would develop. The lawsuits carry allegations of gross negligence and medical malpractice based on a lack of informed consent.

The lawsuit filed in the state court in Columbia has the Medical University of South Carolina and the South Carolina Department of Social Services, as well as the Greenville Hospital System as defendants. The federal lawsuit has been filed in U.S. District Court in Charleston, South Carolina, alleging that the constitutional rights of the child have been violated.


The child, who is now 8 years old, strongly identifies himself as a male and lives as a boy (minus the male organs which were removed by the social workers and doctors, when he was in no position to give consent).

The couple, Pam and Mark Crawford told the media in a phone interview, “We feel strongly that these decisions to permanently alter somebody’s genitalia and their reproductive ability for no medical reason whatsoever is an abhorrent practice and can’t be continued … It’s too late for our son … the damage has been done to him.”

The lawsuits mention that doctors noted the infant had “ambiguous genitals” and had both female and male reproductive organs. The doctors determined that the child could be raised either as a boy or a girl and opted for genital surgery to make him look like a female, though the child’s gender identity was yet to emerge.

Get JD Journal in Your Mail

Subscribe to our FREE daily news alerts and get the latest updates on the most happening events in the legal, business, and celebrity world. You also get your daily dose of humor and entertainment!!

The lawsuit observes, “The doctors knew that sex assignment surgeries on infants with conditions like M.C.’s poses a significant risk of imposing a gender that is ultimately rejected by the patient.”

The Crawfords say, that according to appearance, after taking M.C. in adoption, they initially raised M.C. as a girl from when he was about 20 months old. However, M.C. soon began to exhibit typically male interests and preferred male clothing.



Sr. Staff Attorney


Created within this position is an opportunity to work for a dynamic organization on the front lines...

Apply now

Government / Municipal Law Attorney


Position Available: Government / Municipal Law Attorney (primarily transactional work). Desired E...

Apply now

Fall 2020 Legal Fellowship


NARAL PRO-Choice America Seeks 2020 Fall LEGAL FELLOW Location: Washington, DC This positio...

Apply now

Employment Advocate


Legal Authority is at the forefront of the job placement industry. We are looking for an experi...

Apply now




Search Now

Life Sciences Attorney


Cleveland office of a BCG Attorney Search top ranked law firm seeks Life Sciences Attorney with 1 ye...

Apply Now

Partner-level Corporate Lawyer

USA-NY-New York City

New York City office of a BCG Attorney Search top ranked law firm seeks Partner-level Corporate Lawy...

Apply Now

Transactional Attorney


Boston office of a BCG Attorney Search top ranked law firm seeks Transactional Attorney with 4 years...

Apply Now

Most Popular


To Top