Home

Snoopy Secretary Loses the Case that Her Boss Defamed her in Private Emails to his Wife
Download PDF
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
Loading...

Things didn’t work out in court as a former Thompson Hine secretary had hoped. Valerie Medcalf worked as a legal secretary for George Walsh, but on August 2011 asked for five months of medical leave for postpartum depression. In private emails between himself and his wife, Walsh questioned whether five months was exorbitant, and also made comments on whether she was the most competent of workers. When the secretary gained access to his emails and read them, she confronted the wife and was subsequently terminated; she then sued the firm, but the final ruling has been that communications between spouses are protected by spousal privilege that the comments were opinions, and that the case would therefore be dismissed with prejudice.

The comments in question were reported by The New York Law Journal. One of Ms. Walsh’s responses included, “But generally true post partum depression appears after a few months and I’d ask why they’re asking for five months so early in the process…Is it coincidence that this gives her the rest of the year off and eligible for disability benefits? Sorry, I hope she ok but it just all seems suspect to me.”

Ms. Walsh said, “All the Monday’s and Friday’s off, and other stuff which has been ongoing. You don’t need this. You’ve been very good to her. You deserve someone you can rely on.”

  
What
Where


Mr. Walsh forwarded a photo of Medcalf’s daughter, saying “The first picture of Valerie’s baby. Very cute!!”

Ms. Walsh responded that the girl “is adorable but if [Medcalf] had had a decent shower she would have some nice cotton, clean and non fuzzy blankets to safely sleep [the baby] on. Ugh. It’s good that [Medcalf] seems to have bonded with her though and is exited [sic] enough to share pictures, that’s a good sign.”

Evidently spouses are allowed to gossip like this, and it’s a good thing, because it happens everywhere all the time.

Get JD Journal in Your Mail

Subscribe to our FREE daily news alerts and get the latest updates on the most happening events in the legal, business, and celebrity world. You also get your daily dose of humor and entertainment!!




“Medcalf was fully aware of the allegedly defamatory nature of the Walshes’ email communications when she forwarded them to others,” wrote the judge, also noting that they made no false statement of fact, and that statements of opinion are protected, citing Ollman v. Evans, 471 U.S. 1127 (1985).

He also denied the emails were defamatory:



“Here, the statements made about Medcalf were directed at her character or general qualities, rather than her competence as an assistant, and were not brought to the attention of the general public. They do not constitute defamation per se,” he wrote.

“As to their substance, Evelyn’s comments critiquing Medcalf’s baby’s blankets as unclean and low-quality, or suggesting abusive leave-taking practices by Medcalf, are a far cry from the conduct in cases held non-actionable by the New York courts,” he wrote. “These statements are the sorts of quotidian negative commentary exchanged in countless daily conversations in our free society.”



 

RELEVANT JOBS

Attorney-Litigation-Workers' Compensation-Remote

USA-CA-Los Angeles

Attorney-Los Angeles (remote other than Court appearances or necessary depoistions): EPS, a growi...

Apply now

Trial Attorney

USA-CA-Long Beach

MULTIPLE ATTORNEY POSITIONS OPEN - SEEKING ALL LEVELS OF EXPERIENCE. SUBMIT RESUME IN PDF FORMAT TO&...

Apply now

Senior Law Clerk

USA-CA-Los Angeles

C2 ALAKSA Los Angeles, CA   The Law Clerk III shall provide legal research a...

Apply now

Paralegal

USA-GA-Atlanta

Salary $40,000 - $50,000 a year Job Type Full-time Number of hires for this role 1 ...

Apply now

BCG FEATURED JOB

Locations:

Keyword:



Search Now

Liability Defense Attorney

USA-FL-Fort Lauderdale

Ft. Lauderdale office of our client seeks liability defense attorney with 3+ years of insurance defe...

Apply Now

Senior Family Law Associate Attorney

USA-CA-Murrieta

Murrieta office of a BCG Attorney Search Top Ranked Law Firm seeks senior family law associate attor...

Apply Now

Litigation Associate Attorney

USA-CA-San Francisco

San Francisco office of a BCG Attorney Search Top Ranked Law Firm seeks litigation associate attorne...

Apply Now

Most Popular

SEARCH IN ARCHIVE

To Top