North Carolina Gives up the Fight Against Same-Sex Marriages
North Carolina Gives up the Fight Against Same-Sex Marriages
Ground Zero Cross Stays in Museum, Court Rules
Ground Zero Cross Stays in Museum, Court Rules
Florida Rules Against Same-Sex Marriage Ban
Florida Rules Against Same-Sex Marriage Ban
Washington DC Handgun Ban Judged Unconstitutional
Washington DC Handgun Ban Judged Unconstitutional
Your profile matches an open legal position. Apply now!
Job Listings

IP Attorney’s Lawsuit against LexisNexis and Westlaw Dismissed by Court

On Friday, U.S. District Judge Jed Rakoff dismissed a copyright lawsuit brought by IP attorney Edward White against LexisNexis and Westlaw on the grounds that the companies had made unlawful profits from his copyrighted legal filings. Judge Rakoff dismissed White’s lawsuit without giving any reason, though he said that the reasoning would be provided in a subsequent opinion.

The copyright infringement lawsuit against Elsevier, LexisNexis, and Westlaw had been filed in 2012 by White and another lawyer Kenneth Elan, who practices in New York. The plaintiffs had alleged that their copyrights had been infringed by the defendants who sold the copyrighted legal briefs from their databases.

The lawsuit had alleged, “wholesale unlawful copying of attorneys’ copyrighted work, bundled those works into searchable databases, and sold access to those works in the form of digitized text and images for huge profits.”

Initially, the lawsuit had sought class action status for two groups of lawyers including those who had registered their documents at the U.S. Copyright Office, and those who had not. Later, in May, Rakoff had struck off the proposed subclass of lawyers who had not copyrighted their filings along with parting ways with Elan. However, it is the law in the U.S. that any creation is automatically protected by Copyright after it is created.

Subsequently, White filed an amended complaint without the class certification request and seeking damages based on the inclusion of his copyrighted briefs in Westlaw’s “Litigator” database and in LexisNexis’s “Briefs, Pleadings and Motions” database.



Get JD Journal in Your Mail
Subscribe to our FREE daily news alerts and get the latest updates on the most happening events in the legal, business, and celebrity world. You also get your daily dose of humor and entertainment!!


During arguments on a motion for summary judgment, White argued that “a court’s docket is not a lawless, copyright-free zone,” and that lawyers and law firms own copyrights to their own materials. However, Westlaw and Lexis argued that they used the documents under the doctrine of fair use, and as because the documents were available to the public in general through the Pacer filing system.

The legal research companies also argued that they had value added to the documents by making them searchable and useful for other legal practitioners.

The case is Edward White v. West Publishing Corp, U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, No. 12-1340.

Did you like this? Share it:
IP Attorney’s Lawsuit against LexisNexis and Westlaw Dismissed by Court by

Tagged: ,

Posted by on February 12, 2013. Filed under Legal News. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.
  • Teresa Burnham

    This news story makes the common mistake of referring to works that have not been filed with the U.S. Copyright Office as “not copyrighted.”

    Under current U.S. law a work is protected by Copyright at the moment of creation. No filing is required.

  • aostler

    Thank you for pointing this out. I’ll update the story accordingly – Editor

 

 

Job of the Day
Capital Markets Counsel 3 Attorney
USA-NC-Charlotte

Wells Fargo & Company, a diversified financial services company, is seeking an experienced capital markets Attorney to join its Law Department in its Charlotte, NC office. The individual selected...