Celebrity News

Oakland Raiders Player Gareon Conley Sues Woman Who Accused Him of Rape
Download PDF
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)

Gareon Conley. Photo courtesy of the Las Vegas Review-Journal.

Summary: A football player sued a woman who accused him of rape, saying that her false allegation ruined his reputation and cost him millions. 

Oakland Raiders cornerback Gareon Conley was accused by a woman of sexual assault, and the damning claim resulted in him losing endorsements and his spot in the first round of the 2017 NFL draft. In turn, Conley sued his accuser, and the case is being heard before Judge Joseph Russo of the Cuyahoga County (Ohio) Common Pleas Court.


On April 9, 2017, a 23-year-old student, Brooke Puscian, told Cleveland police that she was raped in a hotel room at the Westin Cleveland Downtown hotel. According to Sports Illustrated, she described her rapist’s appearance and said he had an Ohio State tattoo on his arm.

Hours before, Puscian was dining at Barley House, a restaurant near her hotel, and Conley had also been dining there separately. Conley’s legal team insist the pair had first spoken at the restaurant and Puscian had learned the football player had been drafted into the NFL.

Conley’s lawyers, John Camillus and Kevin Spellacy, said that the football player walked Puscian and her friends from the restaurant to the Westin with the intention of staying the night. Sports Illustrated said that the accounts differed next.

Get JD Journal in Your Mail

Subscribe to our FREE daily news alerts and get the latest updates on the most happening events in the legal, business, and celebrity world. You also get your daily dose of humor and entertainment!!

Puscian said that she met Conley after the football player had approached her while she was in the hotel lobby. Conley’s lawyers said that Puscian was incorrect about when they had first spoken. Puscian said that Conley asked her to get drinks with him in his room, and it appeared that both stories confirmed Puscian went to Conley’s room alone.

Puscian said that once in the room she saw two other people there, a man and a woman, and Conley asked if she wanted to have a foursome. Puscian declined but offered to watch the man and woman have sex. She claimed this was to avoid sleeping with Conley.

Puscian said that as she walked to the bathroom, Conley grabbed her and unbuttoned her pants. She said he pulled her pants down and forced her to have sex while she said, “No stop. It hurts!” After sex, Conley instructed Puscian to leave, she said.

Conley’s account was different than his accuser’s. Conley said that Puscian requested he join her in watching the couple have sex in the bathroom and that he had refused. He said she walked towards the bathroom and took off her pants and bent over, inviting him to have sex with her. Conley said he declined and Puscian got embarassed. He said he asked her to leave and she seemed to be even more humiliated by the encounter.

Later that evening, Puscian called the police and was admitted to a local hospital where she had a rape kit performed on her. The police entered Conley’s room, and he stressed that he had never touched Puscian and that she was angry he had kicked her out.

Days later, TMZ reported the rape allegation and Conley’s reputation was ruined. His representatives had arranged for him to take a lie detector, and even though he had passed,  he was no longer a first round draft pick, instead ending up the Raiders’ number 24 pick. The downgrade of when he was picked cost him about $3 million.

In July 2017, a grand jury declined to indict Conley on the grounds of not finding probable cause, but although he escaped criminal charges, he was open to a civil lawsuit. On April 6, 2018, Puscian sued Conley and 11 defendants, including the Westin Cleveland, for assault, battery, false imprisonment and intentional infliction of emotional distress. Faced with the lawsuit, Conley countersued instead of settled.

Sports Illustrated noted that many people settle to avoid the litigation process, and Conley’s countersuit presents the risk of pretrial discovery. During this process, depositions are taken and evidence is shared. Embarassing information can surface.  But despite this, Conley wanted to move forward and prove his innocence.

On July 2, 2018, Conley sued his accuser for malicious prosecution and for frivolous conduct in filing her claim. He did not sue for defamation, but instead, he focused on her litigation which he said was pursued with intention of hurting him after he rejected her.

“Conley winning a lawsuit and being awarded damages doesn’t mean he would actually be paid. It’s unknown if Puscian has the financial wherewithal to pay a sizable judgment. For Conley, pursuing a case is likely more about restoring his reputation than it is securing a large amount of money from the person he contends falsely accused him,” Sports Illustrated said. “More likely, Conley and Puscian will resolve their dispute out of court in a settlement. The chances of them going to trial are fairly slim.”

What do you think of Gareon Conley? Let us know in the comments below.


Interesting Legal Sites You May Like




Search Now

Litigation/Law and Motion Associate Attorney

USA-CA-Woodland Hills

Woodland Hills office of our client seeks litigation/law and motion associate attorney with preferab...

Apply Now

Commercial Litigation Associate Attorney

USA-CA-Redwood City

Redwood City office of our client seeks commercial litigation associate attorney with 3-5 years of e...

Apply Now

Immigration Law Associate Attorney


Columbus office of our client seeks immigration law associate attorney with 3+ years of experience. ...

Apply Now


Litigation Associate


We are looking for a mid-level litigation associate to join our commercial litigation boutique. T...

Apply now

Paralegal / Legal Assistant

USA-NC-New Bern

General SUMRELL SUGG, PA, a law firm established in 1949 with offices in New Bern and Kins...

Apply now

In-House Counsel


Job Summary: The In-House Counsel will work closely with Falcon’s Executives and will serve...

Apply now

Personal Injury Paralegal

USA-CA-Los Angeles

Prominent and growing law firm in West Los Angeles is seeking a full-time, experienced paralegal wit...

Apply now


To Top