Legal News

How to try a 10-year Old Girl for Manslaughter in Maine?
Download PDF
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)

We can provide very few details because of the obvious sensitivity of the case, but the challenge before the legal system is real enough: How to try, and how to sentence a 10-year old girl for manslaughter? A question that would not have haunted less-developed countries, because they would have treated the incident simply as accidental – at least it would not have made to the police and courts.

However, the justice system, the prosecutors, and judges in Maine are in a fix for now as they cannot find a precedent and are pouring over books of jurisprudence and seeking to find a lead on how such a case had been tried, ever, anywhere in the world. So, if any reader has got a clue to that, your opinions may help out the lot of this child as well as that of the courts in Maine.

Nobody can remember a case when a 10-year old child was tried for manslaughter.


The girl’s name is withheld by the government for clear reasons, and she is currently in the custody of the Department of Health and Human Services in Maine. Further than that her location is not known. The government wouldn’t divulge whether she is in a foster home or some other facility, and we won’t like to probe. The first court date in the case is scheduled in October.

The 10-year girl child from Fairfield is charged with actions that killed a three-month old baby in July while the girl’s mother was babysitting the infant. The mother was present at the time of death, the police were called in, the criminal case was registered, the 10-year girl child was arrested and now tucked away in the labyrinthine depths of the state system awaiting trial and sentencing.

The issues, as expressed by former prosecutor and District Attorney David Crook of Waterville, include whether the 10-year old child was really able to understand that her actions could harm or kill the baby, and in the event of finding the child guilty – what sentence should be imposed.

Get JD Journal in Your Mail

Subscribe to our FREE daily news alerts and get the latest updates on the most happening events in the legal, business, and celebrity world. You also get your daily dose of humor and entertainment!!

As Crook put it: “What should a judge do? … I wouldn’t want to be that judge.”

However, Crook says, the real question is “How does the state make this child capable of re-entering society as a better child and ultimately a better adult?”

At least in this case, the legal system would have to prove to itself and to the public the purpose and meaning of its existence in promoting and maintaining a criminal justice system – rehabilitation, punishment, or betterment of the individual – where does state authority begin and end?



Probate Paralegal / Assistant


Waggoner & Bruehl, PA, a small Law Firm in Pine Island, Florida, is seeking a Probate and Trust Admi...

Apply now


USA-CA-Costa Mesa

Prominent AV Rated Orange County business bankruptcy and commercial litigation law firm boutique see...

Apply now

Litigation Mid-Level Associate Attorney


Hoban Law Group is currently seeking an exceptional mid-to-senior litigation attorney with multi-fac...

Apply now

Real Estate Paralegal - Immediate Opening

USA-NY-Sheepshead Bay

$35,000 to $60,000 Annually Benefits Offered Medical Employment Type Full-Time Why Wo...

Apply now




Search Now

Corporate/Transactional Attorney

USA-IA-Des Moines

Des Moines office of a BCG Attorney Search Top Ranked Law Firm seeks corporate/transactional attorne...

Apply Now

Corporate Attorney / Counsel

USA-NY-New York City

New York City office of a BCG Attorney Search Top Ranked Law Firm seeks corporate attorney with 5+ y...

Apply Now

Housing Finance Associate Attorney


Minneapolis office of a BCG Attorney Search Top Ranked Law Firm seeks a housing finance associate at...

Apply Now

Most Popular


To Top