Legal News

Court Upholds Challenge against Federal Laws on Pornography
Download PDF
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
Loading...

On Monday, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 3rd Circuit reversed a case dismissed by a district judge in 2010. The lawsuit brought by stakeholders of the adult entertainment industry challenges federal laws that require pornography producers to report the ages of performers.

The district judge had held that the government was within its rights in demanding pornography producers to verify the age of performers and maintain identification records open to federal inspection. However, the U.S. Court of Appeals 3rd Circuit reversed the ruling and held that the federal regulations violated the First Amendment and Fourth Amendment rights of pornography producers.

The recordkeeping laws which were created to prevent child pornography and induction of minors in the pornographic industry carry criminal penalties for all publishers and producers in the chain who violate the regulations. Primary producers, secondary producers and website publishers, all come under the ambit of the regulations.

  
What
Where


The lawsuit was brought by the Free Speech Coalition, a pornography trade organization. Fourteen other members of the adult entertainment industry also joined the suit as plaintiffs. They argued that the regulations were excessive, because, instead of being limited to the keeping of records of performers who had the chance to be minors, the regulations required the identification of ‘all’ performers. They argued that where the performers were mature adults who could not be mistaken for children, the requirements were excessive.

The trial judge granted the government’s request to dismiss the suit. However, the 3rd Circuit has disagreed and ruled that the plaintiffs should be given opportunity before the court to prove their point.

The three-judge panel of the Appeals Court held, “If one of the Plaintiffs employs performers that no reasonable person could conclude were minors, then that plaintiff may be able to demonstrate that the Statutes burden substantially more of that plaintiff’s speech than is necessary to protect children from sexual exploitation.”

Get JD Journal in Your Mail

Subscribe to our FREE daily news alerts and get the latest updates on the most happening events in the legal, business, and celebrity world. You also get your daily dose of humor and entertainment!!




Diane Duke, the executive director of the Free Speech Coalition said, “We understand that regulations need to be there. We just need regulations that are reasonable and that we can comply with.” She added that the prospect of facing five years in prison for misfiling a document was unreasonable.

The 3rd Circuit case is Free Speech Coalition et al v. Attorney General of the United States, No. 10-4085.





 

Interesting Legal Sites You May Like


BCG FEATURED JOB

Locations:

Keyword:



Search Now

Litigation Attorney

USA-NV-Henderson

Henderson office of our client seeks litigation attorney with 2+ years of experience. The candidate ...

Apply Now

Senior Litigation Associate Attorney

USA-IL-Chicago

Chicago office of our client seeks senior associate attorney with 7-15 years of litigation experienc...

Apply Now

Commercial Litigation Associate Attorney

USA-MO-Saint Louis

St. Louis office of our client, a Chambers ranked law firm, is actively seeking associates to join o...

Apply Now

RELEVANT JOBS

Bilingual (Spanish) Deportation Defense - Attorney

USA-CA-Sacramento

Boutique immigration law firm in San Francisco is searching for a junior associate to represent indi...

Apply now

Senior Associate - Claims Management

USA-MA-Boston

Our company is a multi-practice, Boston-based law firm offering sophisticated and specialized legal ...

Apply now

STAFF ATTORNEY (PERSONAL INJURY)

USA-FL-Fort Lauderdale

Description: This is a full time Associate Attorney position at a prestigious East Fort Lauderdal...

Apply now

Financial Services and Commercial Litigation Attorney | Lebanon, NH or Brattleboro, VT

USA-VT-Brattleboro

DRM is looking for an associate attorney with a minimum of two years’ experience to join its F...

Apply now

SEARCH IN ARCHIVE

To Top