Biglaw

Malpractice Suit Revived against Katten Muchin Rosenman LLP
Download PDF
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
Loading...

Katten Muchin Rosenman LLP faces a malpractice lawsuit for failing to appreciate the signs that a Ponzi scheme was ongoing within the firm.

Summary: Katten Muchin Rosenman LLP faces a malpractice lawsuit for failing to appreciate the signs that a Ponzi scheme was ongoing within the firm.

On Tuesday, the Seventh Circuit revived a malpractice lawsuit that accuses Katten Muchin Rosenman LLP of ignoring warning signs that should have revealed Tom Petters’ tremendous Ponzi scheme, Law360 reports. The suit argues that a competent attorney would have alerted clients. Peter C. John, Christina D. Harrison and Brigid E. Kennedy of Williams Montgomery & John Ltd. represent Katten.

  
What
Where


Lancelot Investors Fund Ltd. is a hedge fund that provided billions of dollars into the scheme. The bankruptcy trustee for the fund argued that Katten was negligent because it failed to advise Gregory Bell, the fund manager, to investigate the collateral used to support the notes Petters’ companies issued. The collateral was accounts receivable under a supposed deal with Costco Wholesale Corp. that turned out to be completely fake.

Proskauer Rose is facing a malpractice lawsuit.

U.S. District Judge Harry D. Leinenweber dismissed the case last year for failure to state a claim, ruling that Lancelot knew it was taking a risk and that it could not blame a law firm for failing to provide business advice.

Get JD Journal in Your Mail

Subscribe to our FREE daily news alerts and get the latest updates on the most happening events in the legal, business, and celebrity world. You also get your daily dose of humor and entertainment!!




However, on Tuesday, a three-judge panel said that the judge’s decision did not address the complaint’s primary argument that Katten was obligated to inform Bell and the fund with risks associated with allowing repayments to be shuttled through Petters.



Do you think the malpractice suit should proceed against the firm?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

The opinion read, “As the complaint depicts matters, Bell did not appreciate the difference between funds from Costco and funds from Petters. A competent transactions lawyer should have appreciated that the former arrangement offers much better security than the latter and alerted its client. If a client rejects that advice, the lawyer does not need to badger the client; but the complaint alleges that the advice was not offered, leaving the client in the dark about the degree of the risk it was taking.”

A $10 million lawsuit was dismissed against Greenberg Traurig in 2012.

The ruling also asserted that the lower court did not provide any applicable law that distinguishes business advice and legal advice. The opinion states, “It is hard to see how any such bright line could exist, since one function of a transactions lawyer is to counsel the client how different legal structures carry different levels of risk, and then to draft and negotiate contracts that protect the client’s interests. The district court did not cite any Illinois statute or decision holding that a transactions lawyer never needs to supply a client with legal information that affects the degree of business risk attached to a transaction.”

Petters allegedly told investors that their money was being used to purchase merchandise that would be resold to big-box retailers. Petters was convicted in 2009 of coordinating the scheme and was sentenced to a 50-year prison term. Bell received a six year sentence after he admitted he helped support the scheme when it began to fall apart in 2008.

In 2012, lawyers faced a malpractice lawsuit 21 years after the death of a client.

The panel also decided another case that stemmed from the Ponzi scheme on Tuesday. In that case, the panel cleared McGladrey LLP, an accounting firm, of allegations that were brought by the Lancelot bankruptcy trustee. The claims were barred because of in pari delicto, which establishes that a party involved in a fraud cannot sue another party over that fraud. The opinion said, “Claims against Bell may not be worth much (he’s in prison), and securities-law claims against the funds for misstatements in the offering documents aren’t worth much either (they’re bankrupt), but a claim against McGladrey may offer some recompense, if the auditor was indeed negligent or willfully blind. Proceedings on the investors’ claims have been stayed pending resolution of the trustee’s suit. It is time to bring the investors’ claims to the fore.”

Source: Law360

Photo credit: benchmarklitigation.com



 

Interesting Legal Sites You May Like


BCG FEATURED JOB

Locations:

Keyword:



Search Now

Litigation Associate Attorney

USA-SC-Columbia

Columbia office is seeking a commercial litigation attorney with 2-4 years of experience.

Apply Now

Attorney with 3-7 years of commercial/complex litigation experience

USA-CA-Cerritos

Cerritos office of our client seeks attorney with 3-7 years of commercial and complex litigation exp...

Apply Now

Insurance Coverage Associate Attorney

USA-IL-Chicago

Chicago office of our client seeks associate attorney with insurance coverage experience. The candid...

Apply Now

Patent Agent with 1 year of electrical engineering experience

USA-CA-San Francisco

San Francisco office of our client seeks entry level patent agent with 1 year of experience. The can...

Apply Now

RELEVANT JOBS

Corporate / Commercial Attorney | Lebanon, NH

USA-NH-Lebanon

Downs Rachlin Martin PLLC seeks an experienced corporate / commercial attorney to join its Lebanon o...

Apply now

Executive Assistant / Office Administrator

USA-TX-Rosenberg

If you have administrative support experience in the legal industry, or even paralegal expertise,...

Apply now

Associate - Mid-Level - GL Group

USA-NY-Valhalla

Defense firm seeking mid-level associate for Westchester office to fill General Liability position. ...

Apply now

Mortgage Compliance Analyst

USA-MN-Minnetonka

Job Description: Rubicon Mortgage Advisors LLC, a locally-owned, boutique mortgage lender is seeki...

Apply now

SEARCH IN ARCHIVE

To Top