Legal News

Illinois Appellate Court “State Farm Not Responsible for $4.9 Million TCPA Judgment
Download PDF
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)

On May 2, 2014, the Second District Appellate Court in Illinois issued a unanimous opinion in favor of Dykema client State Farm Fire and Casualty Co., reversing the Lake County Circuit Court’s decision. Dykema members Michael Borders and Rosa Tumialan represented State Farm. GM Sign Inc., et al v. State Farm Fire and Casualty Co. (2-13-0593) is the first published state ruling construing the ISO form of the Distribution of Materials in Violation of Statute Exclusion (commonly referred to as the “TCPA exclusion”) under the Illinois law as related to junk fax claims.

The Appellate Court ruled that State Farm had no obligation to defend or indemnify its insured for the tendered complaint involving a stipulated $4.9 million junk fax class action settlement agreed to by its insured. The Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) exclusion applied to the alternative counts of conversion and consumer fraud and that State Farm had no duty to defend or to indemnify the plaintiff in the underlying suit. The court ruled that it’s denial of coverage was not wrongful.


“Fundamentally, the court agreed that the policy exclusion for claims arising directly or indirectly out of actions which violate the TCPA extended to alternative theories premised in the same facts,” said Michael Borders, Office Managing Member of Dykema’s Chicago office. “We are very pleased with this outcome and believe that this decision may have nationwide ramifications for the insurance industry and for similarly styled TCPA class action cases moving forward.”

In 2010, GM Sign, Inc. filed a lawsuit against State Farm insured Michael Schane and his company, Academy Engraving Company, for faxing unsolicited advertisements. In the complaint, it was claimed that the defendant’s conduct violated the TCPA, constituted common law conversion by consuming paper and toner, and constituted a violation of the Illinois Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act. GM Sign and Schane later entered into a stipulated settlement and judgment to be satisfied only from any available insurance. After agreeing to settle, the plaintiff filed an amended complaint for the sole purpose of triggering insurance coverage for the stipulated judgment.

Now, the insurance industry implements exclusions into policies beginning in 2006 that expressly exclude coverage of TCPA and other statutory claims. Class action plaintiffs responded by arguing that these exclusions are ambiguous, unlawfully prevent coverage and/or do not otherwise apply to the alternatively pled common law and statutory claims. The GM Sign rejected these arguments. “This is a significant case that other courts will consider when ruling on similar matters,” said Tumialan, a member of Dykema’s Chicago office. “It is the first published case in Illinois construing the exclusions and among the first to address the scope of a TCPA exclusion nationwide.”

Get JD Journal in Your Mail

Subscribe to our FREE daily news alerts and get the latest updates on the most happening events in the legal, business, and celebrity world. You also get your daily dose of humor and entertainment!!

Image credit:



Transactional Tax Partner with Big Law Experience (100% work from home)


Culhane Meadows is seeking a seasoned tax attorney with at least 8 years of practice in general...

Apply now

Labor & Employment Partner (100% Work From Home)


Culhane Meadows PLLC, one of the largest non-traditional distributed law firms in the country, ...

Apply now

Technology and Outsourcing Partner (100% Work from Home)


Culhane Meadows PLLC is actively seeking an experienced and self-motivated Technology and ...

Apply now


USA-MO-Jefferson City

Attorney position available in the areas of Medical Malpractice Defense, Employment Defense and...

Apply now




Search Now

Junior To Mid-Level Patent Associate Attorney


Doral office of a BCG Attorney Search Top Ranked Law Firm seeks a junior to mid-level patent associa...

Apply Now

Commercial Litigation Attorney


Lafayette office of a BCG Attorney Search Top Ranked Law Firm seeks a commercial litigation attorney...

Apply Now

Mid-level Intellectual Property Litigation Associate Attorney

USA-CA-Los Angeles

Los Angeles office of a BCG Attorney Search Top Ranked Law Firm seeks a mid-level intellectual prope...

Apply Now

Most Popular


To Top