Legal News

2nd Circuit Says SEC Can Recoup Money Even Where Insider Trader Didn’t Have Direct Benefits
Download PDF
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)


Earlier this week, a divided (2-1) 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals passed a ruling that allows the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission to cover an important loophole and move to recoup money from insider trading profits, where the insider trader did not have direct personal benefits.


Writing for the majority, Circuit Judge Gerard Lynch wrote, “Whether the defendant’s motive is direct economic profit, self-aggrandizement, psychic satisfaction from benefiting a loved one, or future profits by enhancing one’s reputation as a successful fund manager, the insider trader who trades for another’s account has engaged in a fraud, secured a benefit thereby, and directed the profits of the fraud where he has chosen them to go.”

The ruling was given in the matter of Joseph Contorinis, former portfolio manager of Jefferies Group Inc., who had been convicted in 2010 for insider trading. Contorinis will have to pay back $7.26 million of alleged illegal profit he made for the firm’s Paragon Fund, along with an interest of $2.42 million.

In the court of first instance, U.S. District Judge Richard Sullivan in Manhattan had ordered Contorinins to forfeit $427,875 in the associated criminal case. In its ruling, the 2nd Circuit upheld the penalty imposed by Sullivan.

Get JD Journal in Your Mail

Subscribe to our FREE daily news alerts and get the latest updates on the most happening events in the legal, business, and celebrity world. You also get your daily dose of humor and entertainment!!

Contorinis had argued that the profit made by Paragon due to his machinations was not within his personal control and he should not be liable to disgorge that profit.

In his dissent Judge Denny Chin agreed with Contorinis’ argument and said, “While Contorinis undeniably deserved to be punished, disgorgement was not the proper mechanism.” Chin was of the opinion that disgorgement should be remedial and not punitive.

Contorinins, 49, is currently serving a six-year prison term stemming from his conviction for securities fraud and conspiracy over trades in supermarket chain Albertsons Inc ahead of its buyout in 2006.



Litigation Attorney


Responsibilities The candidate should be able to independently manage own caseload through all ph...

Apply now

Sr. Trial Attorney


Bodily Injury Auto, Bodily Injury Commercial, Bodily Injury Homeowners, Commercial Auto, Commercial ...

Apply now

Landlord Tenant Counsel (Corporate)

USA-MD-College Park

WHAT WE ARE LOOKING FOR: This position advises executive, senior management and managers on various...

Apply now

Attorney with 1+ year experience - Position is in Probate Law


Looking for an associate attorney with at least one year of experience.  We are a boutique prob...

Apply now




Search Now

Business and Transactional Associate Attorney


Middletown office of a BCG Attorney Search Top Ranked Law Firm seeks business and transactional asso...

Apply Now

Business and Transactional Associate Attorney


Hartford office of a BCG Attorney Search Top Ranked Law Firm seeks business and transactional associ...

Apply Now

Business and Transactional Associate Attorney

USA-CT-East Haven

East Haven office of a BCG Attorney Search Top Ranked Law Firm seeks business and transactional asso...

Apply Now

Most Popular


To Top