Legal News

Appeals Court Declines Rehearing of Journalist in CIA Leak Case
Download PDF
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)

On Tuesday, the full United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit declined to hear an appeal by James Risen, reporter for NY Times, against a previous court order that asks him to testify against a source.

The 13-1 decision means the closely watched case may now make its way to the Supreme Court as the issues both for and against Risen’s stand are important for democracy. The case has been held important both for national security, as well as for the freedom of press, and where both have to draw the lines in asserting their interests.


In July, a three-judge panel had ordered Mr. Risen to testify in the trial of CIA officer Jeffrey Sterling. Risen appealed, and received a 13-1 rejection of his petition. However, the sole voice of dissent that of Judge Roger L. Gregory, seems like the sole voice of reason, somehow in a panel strangled by rules and divorced from reality.

While the judges rejecting Risen’s appeal did not explain their reasons, Gregory observed in his written dissent that for “public opinion to serve as a meaningful check on governmental power, the press must be free to report to the people the government’s use (or misuse) of that power.”

Gregory also commented, “some reporters, including the one in this case, may be imprisoned for failing to reveal their sources, even though reporters seek only to shed light on the workings of our government in the name of its citizens.”

Get JD Journal in Your Mail

Subscribe to our FREE daily news alerts and get the latest updates on the most happening events in the legal, business, and celebrity world. You also get your daily dose of humor and entertainment!!

In the July ruling against Risen, the judges had observed that reporters cannot claim protection of the First Amendment if they are asked to testify against their sources of unauthorized leaks of government secrets.

Such a stand, of course, totally handicaps the media from learning or exposing government wrongdoings, as no source would be coming forward under such circumstances to inform the public.



Paralegal for Midtown Real Estate Firm

USA-NY-New York City

Responsibilities include: Handle all duties related to closing documents including: deeds, mem...

Apply now

Associate Attorney

USA-CA-Los Angeles

Abramson Labor Group, a firm that exclusively focuses on Labor & Employment Law, is currently seekin...

Apply now

Workers Compensation Attorney

USA-CA-Los Angeles

Abramson Labor Group, a firm that focuses on Labor & Employment Law, is currently seeking a Workers ...

Apply now

Criminal Law Contract Attorney

USA-CA-San Jose

LEVEL THE PLAYING FIELD! Ideal opportunity for growing or supplementing your practice.  T...

Apply now




Search Now

Personal Injury Litigator


Northern Virginia office of our client is seeking a personal injury litigator with 4+ years of stron...

Apply Now

Associate Attorney


Larkspur office of our client seeks an associate attorney with 4-6 years of experience/background pr...

Apply Now

Associate Attorney

USA-MI-Bloomfield Hills

Bloomfield Hills office of a BCG Attorney Search Top Ranked Law Firm seeks an associate attorney wit...

Apply Now

Most Popular


To Top