Legal News

Appeals Court Rules Smelling Pot on a Person isn’t Probable Cause for Warrantless Search of His Vehicle
Download PDF
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)

On Tuesday, the Court of Appeals, Nebraska found that to justify the probable cause for a warrantless search and seizure of a vehicle, law enforcement needs to show smell of marijuana was emanating from the vehicle and not just from the body of the vehicle owner standing away from his vehicle.

In the instant case, a Grand Island man, Roger Dalland and his girlfriend were called to the Aurora Police Department where he and his girlfriend were interviewed separately. Dalland was interviewed first, and after about an hour was allowed to leave. While his girlfriend was being interviewed, Dalland waited outside.

At that time, Cpl. Chad Mertz happened to pass by, and the sleuth smelled pot on Dalland. He asked Dalland whether he had been smoking pot. Dalland, who had been at the police department premises for more than an hour, answered to the negative, but said earlier in the day he had been with persons who were smoking pot.


Mertz didn’t say anything, but followed Dalland’s girlfriend to the car and when the couple were ready to leave, he knocked and asked Dalland to get out of the vehicle. Then he patted him down, followed through with a search of the vehicle, seized three syringes with traces of meth and charged Dalland with possession of meth.

At a hearing to suppress the evidence, Mertz testified that Dalland had told him the needles were in his car before he began his warrantless search. However, that testimony contradicted with Mertz’s affidavit which clearly mentioned and claimed that smelling marijuana on Dalland was the probable cause upon which the officer searched the car without a warrant.

The trial court agreed, accepted the evidence and convicted Dalland. However, Dalland argued that his 4th Amendment rights had been violated.

Get JD Journal in Your Mail

Subscribe to our FREE daily news alerts and get the latest updates on the most happening events in the legal, business, and celebrity world. You also get your daily dose of humor and entertainment!!

In overturning the conviction and explaining what constitutes probable cause, the Nebraska Court of Appeals cited, among many other cases, the precedent of U.S. vs. Ross established by the U.S. Supreme Court, in which while illustrating what is acceptable as “probable cause” for warrantless search, the Supreme Court observed:

“Just as probable cause to believe that a stolen lawnmower may be found in a garage will not support a warrant to search an upstairs bedroom, probable cause to believe that undocumented aliens are being transported in a van will not justify a warrantless search of a suitcase. Probable cause to believe that a container placed in the trunk of a taxi contains contraband or evidence does not justify a search of the entire cab…”

Accordingly, the Court of Appeals overturned Dalland’s conviction and remanded the case to the lower court holding smelling marijuana on Dalland’s body (and not vehicle) was probable cause to search his person, but not his car. Hence, the warrantless search and seizure that retrieved the needles leading to Dalland’s conviction was made in violation of his constitutional rights under the 4th Amendment.


Interesting Legal Sites You May Like




Search Now

Matrimonial/Family Law Attorney


Walden office of our client seeks matrimonial/family law attorney with 3-5 years of experience. The ...

Apply Now

Matrimonial Attorney

USA-NY-Garden City South

Garden City South office of our client seeks matrimonial attorney with experience. The candidate wil...

Apply Now

Probate Litigation Attorney


Orlando office of our client seeks probate litigation attorney with 3+ years of experience.

Apply Now


Legal Department Manager


Acclaim Credit Technologies is seeking full time individual for our legal department. Job requiremen...

Apply now

Workers' Rights Coordinator Attorney

USA-CA-San Francisco

La Raza Centro Legal Workers\' Rights Coordinating Attorney   JOB ANNOUNCEMENT Posi...

Apply now

Senior Law Coordinator Attorney

USA-CA-San Francisco

SENIOR LAW COORDINATING ATTORNEY La Raza Centro Legal is currently accepting applications for a c...

Apply now

Immigration Law Coordinator Attorney

USA-CA-San Francisco

Immigration Program Coordinating Attorney The Immigration Program Coordinating Attorney at La Raz...

Apply now


To Top