New Research Finds That Law School Rankings Complicate Diversity Efforts
Download PDF
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)

New research may indicate that U.S. News and World Report law school rankings do not help law schools create a more diverse student body. There is pressure to hold or improve a school’s current ranking and this can mean fewer openings for students from diverse backgrounds. These students may score lower on the LSAT and have lower grade point averages. “Selectivity” makes up a quarter of a school’s ranking in U.S. News calculations and takes into account LSAT scores, undergraduate grades and schools’ degree of exclusivity in accepting prospective students.

U.S. News has a law school diversity index but that data is not a factor in the overall rankings. Bob Morse, the Director of Data Research for the U.S. News rankings says that diversity is a “complicated issue” and it does not fit easily into the rankings formula.

Law school admissions officers told researchers that U.S. News rankings have forced them to place a greater emphasis on test scores because it is easier to control a school’s median LSAT score than it is for them to control their “reputation” scores. Reputation scores are based on the polling of lawyers, judges and administrators at peer schools. This makes a school less apt to admit students with lower LSAT scores and an emphasis is placed on giving merit based scholarships to students with high test scores, rather than need based aid that usually goes to economically disadvantaged students. There are concerns that these rankings do not recognize or downgrade a school which may have a different emphasis in the admissions process, such as admitting people with a history of public service who may not have top LSAT scores.


This research was conducted by sociology professors Wendy Espeland of Northwestern University and Michael Sauder of the University of Iowa. The pair has been studying the impact of U.S. News rankings on graduate programs since 2003. Espeland and Sauder co-authored a recent paper analyzing how law school management is influenced by the rankings. Diversity was considered as part of their larger research and they published their findings in “Rankings and Diversity” in the fall 2009 issue of the Southern California Review of Law and Social Justice.

Espeland and Sauder recommend that U.S. News allow schools to opt out of being ranked if they choose and account for diversity in their rankings process. Morse believes there is no fair and meaningful way to account for diversity and that it is not something U.S. News can do in their rankings. He does support Espeland and Sauder’s recommendations that schools understand that these rankings measure median LSAT and grade levels and not averages. This allows schools to accept students with lower test scores and grades without lowering the overall median GPA and LSAT score statistics.

Get JD Journal in Your Mail

Subscribe to our FREE daily news alerts and get the latest updates on the most happening events in the legal, business, and celebrity world. You also get your daily dose of humor and entertainment!!




USA-NY-Forest Hills

401K, Medical Full-Time   We are a firm that exclusively handles divorce and fami...

Apply now

Business Law Associate Attorney


The Charleston Group is seeking a business law attorney. Applicant must have experience in reviewing...

Apply now

Litigation Associate Attorney


The Charleston Group, a boutique, full-service business law and civil litigation law firm, is seekin...

Apply now

Office Admini​strator


Office Admini​strator.  This position is permanent and full-time. Employee is responsible...

Apply now




Search Now

Public Finance Associate Attorney


Seattle office of a BCG Attorney Search Top Ranked Law Firm seeks a public finance associate attorne...

Apply Now

Complex Civil Litigation Associate Attorney

USA-NY-New York City

New York City office of boutique firm seeks associate attorney with 4-6 years of complex civil litig...

Apply Now

Mid-Senior level Corporate Capital Markets/Securities Associate Attorney


Chicago office of a BCG Attorney Search Top Ranked Law Firm seeks mid-senior level corporate capital...

Apply Now

Most Popular


To Top