Legal Technology News

Supreme Court to Hear Apple Samsung Fight
Download PDF

Apple samsung

Summary:  The fight between Apple and Samsung regarding their patent infringements on the iPhone has reached the highest court with arguments starting Tuesday.

Nearly six years has gone by with Apple and Samsung still battling over patents and smartphone designs. Now the fight will go before the top court tomorrow. The Supreme Court will consider the patent infringement issue as they hear both sides’ arguments. Samsung is at risk of paying $548 million to Apple for overstepping on their patent.

  
What
Where


Samsung calls the amount “disproportionate” for the patent infringement accusations by Apple regarding the profits from 11 disputed smartphones. Apple is adamant that Samsung blatantly copied various iPhone design features and wants the reward of $399 million and the additional $150 million for the pinch-to-zoom patent.

Read $120 Million Jury Verdict against Samsung Overturned.

The patents owned by Apple cover “the rounded corners of its phones, the rim that surrounds the front face and the grid of icons that users view.” A federal court in San Jose ruled in December that Samsung owed Apple the $548 million for using their patents. An appeals court ruled in Samsung’s favor based on their argument that “the ruling was akin to awarding the entire profits on a car because of an infringing cup-holder.”

Get JD Journal in Your Mail

Subscribe to our FREE daily news alerts and get the latest updates on the most happening events in the legal, business, and celebrity world. You also get your daily dose of humor and entertainment!!




The Supreme Court will be determining if the patent infringement covers individual components or the entire product. Apple states they “failed to show that the patented designs applied only to part of its phones.” Samsung has already paid the reward but there is a stipulation that could require Apple to pay back the money should the ruling be reversed.

See Court of Appeals Rules in Favor of Samsung, Reversing $382 Million of $930 Million Verdict for Apple.



The case will be the first design patent dispute case to be heard in 120 years. The last case to be heard was in the 1890s over carpet design patents and then in the 1870s for spoon handles.

Do you think Apple should be rewarded with the full profits from the phones or only a portion? Tell us in the comments below.

To learn more about the fight between Apple and Samsung, read Patent-Infringement Ruling Reinstated Against Samsung.

Photo: nbcwashington.com

 

Most Popular

Legal Career Resources

March 28, 2017 Attorneys Need to Keep Working with the Best Law Firm as Long as Possible

Summary: An attorney will only have success if they keep working in the best law firm possible and do not give up on their career. Leaving a top law firm or any law firm is a big decision that should […]

read more

SEARCH IN ARCHIVE

To Top