Free Market Evaluation - Send us your resume and we will give you free feedback
International Attorney Jobs: International Legal Jobs for Americans
International Attorney Jobs: International Legal Jobs for Americans
7 Must Read Books about the Legal Profession
7 Must Read Books about the Legal Profession
The Top 10 Law Schools by Number of Applications
The Top 10 Law Schools by Number of Applications
Foley & Lardner Partner Avoids Supreme Court Punishment
Foley & Lardner Partner Avoids Supreme Court Punishment
Legal Job Listings
Download PDF

Barbie Evades Bratz Slap of Antitrust Lawsuit View Count: 41

Mattel, maker of the fashion doll Barbie line, has won the dismissal of the antitrust lawsuit brought against them by MGA Entertainment, maker of the fashion doll Bratz line. This is just the latest in a fierce competition between Mattel, the mega-giant toy company, biggest in the world, and MGA, much smaller in comparison.

The war between the two companies began when Barbie designer Carter Bryant left Mattel to work for MGA and to create the Bratz line. In April 2004, Mattel sued and lost a claim that they owned intellectual rights to the Bratz dolls — but this was only after Mattel was awarded $100 million in 2008, only to lose it again in an appeals ruling in 2010.

Then in August, 2011 MGA was awarded $310 million in damages for attorney’s fees and legal costs in compensation for the long, bitter legal feuds against Mattel.

The latest is the suit from MGA that Mattel has violated the Sherman antitrust law, aiming to “litigate MGA to death,” with is great resources, and to solidify their dominance in the fashion doll market. Isaac Larian, MGA Chief Executive offer, is accusing Mattel of ruining Hasbro’s 2006 offer to buy Bratz for $1.1 billion. MGA is seeking $2 billion in damages.

Get JD Journal in Your Mail
Subscribe to our FREE daily news alerts and get the latest updates on the most happening events in the legal, business, and celebrity world. You also get your daily dose of humor and entertainment!!




Though U.S. District Judge David O. Carter awarded the $309 million settlement to MGA, this did not influence the latest antitrust lawsuit. MGA has noted that Mattel intimidated their vendors to bar business with MGA, and manipulated courts to submerge MGA’s business.

“Until Mattel launched its blitzkrieg on Bratz, MGA had been the most effective and serious competitor of Mattel in the fashion doll market,” claimed the federal lawsuit. “Accordingly, Mattel’s conduct has served to reinforce its fashion doll monopoly, and to impair the ability of MGA and others to compete in the relevant fashion doll market.

The antitrust suit was dropped on what MGA calls a technicality. The courts said that “MGA’s current and prior claims are the same,” and the law “bars a later claim that is based on allegation of misconduct of which the claimant was previously aware and has alleged in the prior case,” said U.S district Judge David Carter, dismissing the case with prejudice, so that it cannot be brought up again.

Larian seeks to appeal. “The judge dismissed on a technicality. We will pursue Mattel accordingly until they stop their monopolistic behavior.”

Meanwhile, Mattel Alan Hilowitz naturally finds the decision pleasing. Yet it seems the dispute between the Bratz and Barbie are far from over.

Barbie Evades Bratz Slap of Antitrust Lawsuit by

  • Erin Baldwin

    That’s not too surprising since Mattel’s lawyer is Jennifer Keller who shares a law office with OC District Attorney Tony Rackaukas’s wife, Kay. Makes it easier to “muscle” people around if you know what I mean.

  • Eva Mithad

    Kay is Tony Rackauckas’s ex-wife. They divorced many years ago and he remarried.

    And since when does a woman in a four-lawyer firm ” muscle” name partners in a 400 attorney firm?

    Nice try, Mattel.

Tagged: , , ,

Daniel June Posted by on February 23, 2012. Filed under Home,Legal News. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

 

 

Job of the Day
Family Law Paralegals
USA-FL-West Palm Beach
Greenstein & Associates, a mid-sized law firm in Palm Beach County, seeks an experienced Family Law Paralegal with a background handling contested and uncontested dissolution, custody and support...


Apply now

Related Posts: